Showing posts with label Opinion. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Opinion. Show all posts
Thursday, July 23, 2009

ITV Interview With Franz Tost And Giorgio Ascanelli

The ITV website recently carried an interview with Toro Rosso team principal Franz Tost and technical director Giorgio Ascanelli. As one of the STR drivers, Sebastien Buemi was focal to the discussion. Here I give a run down on what was said relating to Buemi.

Obviously Sebastien Buemi was discussed in detail, with a question asking how they rated Buemi's performance. I'll quote the response by Franz Tost in full:

Buemi has done a really good job so far. You have to consider that, as the only rookie on the grid this year, he is the first real victim of the in-season testing ban.

He had therefore never driven at circuits like Silverstone or the Nurburgring in a Formula 1 car, which is completely different to tackling them in other types of car.

While he knows the tracks from Formula 3 or GP2, it is not at all the same, because F1 is much more complex and little details like how track conditions usually change from the third free practice session on Saturday morning to qualifying that same afternoon, are all part of the package that only comes with experience.

Up until this year, we would have done a minimum of three days testing at Silverstone, for example, prior to the British Grand Prix and at many other race venues.

But you can’t have everything and while we are saving money through not testing, the downside is that young drivers will suffer.

What we can say is that Buemi will be a much more complete driver for the 2010 season.

This is a promising sign for Sebastien Buemi, especially in the same week where Toro Rosso sacked Sebastien Bordais for alleged under-performance.

Most people would agree that on balance Buemi has outperformed Bourdais over the course of the season so far. However, his results haven't been great - mostly due to an under performing car rather than his skills - and Toro Rosso are getting a reputation for sacking people (Bourdais, Liuzzi, Speed).

Tost also admitted that they've greatly missed Sebastien Vettel, who moved on to STR's parent team Red Bull at the start of the year.

There's a worry that Buemi will be compared to Vettel's performance last year, which is unfair for a number of reasons: Vettel had experience as a tester in an F1 car going into last year, while Buemi has had very little testing time and no one can deny that the car this year is slower than it's rivals.

Tost's response shows that Toro Rosso know that Buemi has been a victim of the in-season testing ban and that he won't mature as quickly as other drivers have been able to in the past. It also implies that STR believe in Sebastien Buemi and will stick with him going into the 2010 season.

Later in the interview, when Giorgio Ascanelli was discussing the reasons why Toro Rosso have struggled, he brought up Buemi's inexperience as one of the reasons (in that it's harder for him to adapt to changes to the car).

When asked it that was a criticism of Buemi, Ascanelli said "absolutely not" and re-iterated that Buemi's only had limited time in an F1 car and that they couldn't expect any more of him, saying:

We cannot expect him to learn any faster: he is trying his best and doing a good job.

The interview also included discussion about why Toro Rosso have struggled this year and the upgrades that the STR4 will receive in the upcoming Hungarian Grand Prix.

When asked why STR have struggled, Franz Tost indicated that for financial reasons they made a conscious decision to delay major updates to the car and bundle them into one major update package (the one coming in the next GP). As a result, Toro Rosso have fallen behind the other teams, who have all added major updates to their cars. For example, Tost points out that Toro Rosso are the only team on the grid not to have included a double deck diffuser.

This explains why the recent races have been so much of a struggle for Toro Rosso and Sebastien Buemi. Hopefully the coming updates will make the STR4 competitive again and give Buemi a chance to challenge for points.

Wednesday, April 1, 2009

Decision To Give Sebastien Buemi STR Drive Vindicated

Yesterday, Autosport.com carried a story titled Toro Rosso vindicated by Buemi decision, in which Helmut Marko, the Red Bull Motorsport Advisor says he has been vindicated in his decision to give Sebastien Buemi a seat in the Toro Rosso car for the 2009 Formula One championship.

There have been question marks over the decision to give Buemi an F1 drive because his GP2 form was not as impressive as some of the other drivers who have made the step up. For example, Buemi didn't win the GP2 championship, like other drivers such as Lewis Hamilton, Sebastien Vettel, Nico Rosberg etc have. Many felt he was promoted to F1 prematurely.

You all know where I stand - after all, I created a blog about Sebastien Buemi, so I obviously rate him pretty highly - but even I have to acknowledge that there are some question marks.

Sebastien went some way to answering those questions and silencing any critics with his great performance in Melbourne, where he became one of only 69 drivers to have scored points on debut. I think he's shown enough to be given time to develop his potential.

Helmut Marko obviously agrees strongly. In the Autosport article, he reveals that he had to work hard to convince people within Red Bull that Buemi was ready for F1 and that he now feels vindicated in the decision:

I had to fight very hard to put him in the car. All the experts know that I made the right choice.

Sebastien Buemi also came out and had a shot at his detractors, saying:

The people who say this don't understand anything about racing. If you look at the car we had last year in GP2, and the comparison with my teammate, I was a lot better. Now being in F1, everyone knows what a Toro Rosso can do, and I could do the job.

Strong words from the pair. Whilst I agree with them and think that Buemi has the makings of a very good Formula 1 driver, it's not the time to get overexcited. He needs to keep his feet on the ground and make sure that he finishes the next race in Sepang.

The ITV form card for Sepang agrees with all of this:

Given his low-key junior record, there were doubts about whether Buemi was the right man to fill Vettel's shoes at Toro Rosso. His Melbourne performance answered a lot of those concerns, though. Buemi not only outqualified his more experienced team-mate Bourdais, but ran in the top five in the race, went wheel to wheel with Hamilton and Massa, and finished seventh. Now the challenge is to keep that great momentum going.

That sums it up nicely: doubts, great start, must keep it going.

Sebastien Buemi has to keep his head screwed on tightly. He'll need the assistance of the Toro Rosso team to do that, but I think that he's mature enough to handle the pressures of F1 without too much trouble. What do you think?

Monday, March 30, 2009

Sebastien Buemi Ignored By The Chequered Flag

I'm a big fan of the BBC's The Chequered Flag Formula 1 podcast and I've really missed it over the winter.

After a great opening race in Melbourne, which was full of great racing, clashes and which had a fairytale ending, I listened to their post race podcast with excitement. It was a great podcast as usual, but I was disappointed that they didn't find time to even mention Sebastien Buemi's great performance on debut.

I understand that there were many big stories, which have to take precedence - things such as:

  • The amazing Brawn GP one two finish
  • The clash between Sebastian Vettel and Robert Kubica, which cost them both a place on the podium (and the excellent performance of both drivers before that)
  • Lewis Hamiliton's fantastic third, in a car that no one thought could make it into the points
  • Toyota's charge through the pack, after starting in pit lane.
  • Jarno Trulli's penalty which cost him a place on the podium
  • The effectiveness of KERS in overtaking and defending positions
  • Ferrari's horrible weekend
I've probably missed some stories too. So I understand that Sebastien Buemi and Toro Rosso are not going to be a big story or mentioned at the top of the podcast.

However, I'm pretty sure that last year, the Chequered Flag post race podcast went through all the F1 drivers, at least briefly. This time round they totally ignored the STR drivers (and Force India's drivers as well for that matter).

That's disappointing in it's own right, but given that Sebastien Buemi scored in his first race (one of only 69 drivers to ever do this), soundly beat his more experienced teammate, and ran as high as 4th at one point, it's disappointing that they didn't mention Buemi for his achievement.

Here's hoping that The Chequered Flag covers all the drivers in future.

Thursday, March 26, 2009

NY Times F1 Blog Don't Fancy Sebastien Buemi

I've just been reading the New York Times Formula 1 Blog's look at the 2009 F1 driver lineup and they aren't too flattering toward Toro Rosso driver Sebastien Buemi.

Joe Saward from grandprix.com and Brad Spurgeon from IHT discuss him as follows:

SAWARD: I don’t understand why Buemi is there. He has won nothing significant in his career.

SPURGEON: Buemi, I think, is the first driver I can remember in the recent history of F1 to get a drive in the sport after never having won a racing car championship in his whole career. He won karting titles, but nothing in five or six years of cars! But he has Red Bull backing.

They go on to criticise Red Bull's record of choosing drivers and generally agree that Sebastien Buemi was only chosen because Red Bull have already invested so much in him.

I can't say that their views are flat out wrong, but I do think they are a little harsh.

Sure, Sebastien hasn't won a title in five or six years of cars, but he's been constantly improving, then stepping up to the next level, then improving, etc. He's not far off the pace. That's a far cry from winning championships, but I think he's got enough about him to be a successful F1 driver.

I'm not saying he'll be as good as Lewis Hamilton or Sebastian Vettel, but there's something about him that I think is promising.

Time will tell. What do you think?